Part 2 of my Trans-lations series.
"I don’t get how what Synthia China Blast did should have any bearing on whether people support prisoners’ basic rights."
"As a male, Synthia China Blast should get whatever he wants, whenever he wants. Raping and killing little girls has no bearing on this… After all, men rule all and should be catered to in every possible way. The rights of female prisoners are non-existent. If a rapist and girl-murderer wants to be housed with them, it is his right to be housed with them and rape them at will.
Wow transphobes are magical. How do you turn “prisoners are human beings” into “let men rape and murder”?
Actually it’s “how on earth is a taxpayer-funded sex change and placement among female prisoners for a violent rapist a ‘basic right’”, but whatever floats your boat, I suppose.
When someone goes to prison the state takes over for providing necessary medical care, if you wouldn’t deny a prisoner an organ transplant than you shouldn’t deny them gender confirmation surgery which is just as necessary. Women go to women’s prison, this shouldn’t be that shocking.
Man is perfectly comfortable raping and murdering women from his position of privilege as a man. Goes to prison, suddenly decides he was “really a woman all along”, demands to be placed in women’s prison.
This sound perfectly sane and okay to you?
I’d say you’re vile, but “astonishingiy naive” is probably closer to the mark.
Yes she was female all along, that is what it means to be trans, you are born a girl but no one else seems to understand that. So yes it seems sane to me for a woman to go to a women’s prison, as that is where we send women who are convicted of a crime. If we are going to call someone naive it would have to be you, I mean you seem to believe that cis women are incapable of rape or murder.
No, actually, that’s not what trans means.
Trans means that someone’s biological reality (their sex) is incongruent with their perception of themselves in the world and the subsequent social roles (gender).
If Morales was female, he’d never have been able to rape that poor little girl, because he wouldn’t have a dick.
Which he does.
So he’s not female.
Trans women are not female. If they were, they wouldn’t be trans. That’s the whole point of the endeavour.
Trans women have testes, produce testosterone and have small gametes known as spermatozoa.
Women, females, have ovaries, produce estrogen and have large gametes known as oocytes (or ova).
They’re actually the furthest thing from female.
First, no you do not need a penis to rape. Like even if we take your criminally narrow definition of rape, people with out penises are still capable of it. They still have fingers, tongues, and any manner of foreign objects which they could use to penetrate someone. Second trans women aren’t female if you think the only thing relevant about womanhood is a vagina, which would make you a misogynist.
As a biological male, you have exactly zero standing to define misogyny. Just as I do not define racism as a white person, and need to sit down and shut up when black people talk about racism, you need to sit down and shut up when women talk about misogyny.